How Modern Hybrid Lever Espresso Machines Work
- pizzaman383
- Supporter ❤
What makes an espresso machine a modern/hybrid lever?
- group head heated separately from boilers
- electronic control of when water flows to group
- pressure relief/shot stopper to end the shot when desired
This combination can make the modern hybrid lever work more like a modern saturated group espresso machine while keeping the essential characteristics of the classic lever espreso machine.
Here is a diagram showing how a hypothetical double boiler modern spring lever group espresso machine works. The Nurri, ACS, and others are likely to be similarly configured - I don't have access to any of them so I don't know for sure. The purpose of this is to describe how things can work and what is possible. Different machines may well have made different choices on how to provide similar capabilities.
The typical operation works by having movement of the lever and/or a manual switch trigger water flow into the group with a check valve holding the water in the group when the lever is released to allow the spring to start providing the shot pressure. When the shot is done a switch triggers the solenoid to release the pressure from the group and the water flows through an orifice that reduces the flow so that the lever doesn't move too flash and so it doesn't splash. Additional switches may be used to trigger water flow through the group or to the drip tray independantly of making a shot.
One innovative HB member came up with a method to modify a Strega to have a pressure release/shot stopper. Here is a diagram showing how I think a strega can be modified to operate similarly. The only changes required are adding the pressure release components. Here is a link: Bezzera Strega mods
Here is a diagram of BigEric's DIY Double Boiler Lever he recently built. While based on the hypothetical double boiler hybrid lever configuration it has further notable differences.
A gear pump controlled by a timer is used to control the volume of water being fed into the group cylinder. This allows for complete filling of the cylinder to ensure the largest possible shot volume and the highest possible spring pressure during the shot.
Incoming water is fed through a thermoblock to bring its temperature close to the brew boiler temperature then is fed into the brew boiler assembly which uses a coil wrapped around the boiler to dampen temperature fluctuations while the group cylinder fills. The volume of the boiler and preheat coil is sized to ensure that the water being fed into the full group cylinder is all the as close to the same temperature as possible.
An LSM group is used with modifications to initiate the timer when the group lever reaches the bottom of its travel. In addition, the internals of the preinfusion valve are removed to allow water flow to and from the group regardless of the position of the lever. The group head is heated by both cartridge heaters and a silicon band heater with a temperature sensor half-way up the group cylinder in order to reduce the temperature variations.
Here is a diagram of the current (and final?) configuration of my DIY Double Dipper Lever that now operates like a modern/hybrid lever. My goal was to be able to make each shot have the same temperature profile regardless of how much time had passed between the previous shot and the next. More specifcally, being able to make the next shot immediately after the prior shot with no temperature change has been my ultimate goal. There are some notable differences in my configuration.
Because the Condor group I used doesn't have a place for cartridge heaters I place them in a copper plate to which the group head is mounted. A band heater is installed around the group head bell to provide better heat control of the group head. I found that this was necessary to keep the group head temperature consistent from shot to shot. Without it the machine required an offset between the brew boiler and group head temperatures plus some amount of delay between shots for the group head to cool.
The brew boiler is fed by water from the steam boiler that has been mixed with line water to provide water that is a few degrees under the temperature of the brew boiler to ensure quick recovery without overshooting. This is done using the same mixing valve commonly used to control the temperature of the hot water tap on commercial espresso machines. The output of the mixing assembly goes into a preheat coil wound around the brew boiler then into the boiler to damp out changes in brew boiler temperature introduced by the incoming water. The volume of the brew boiler and preheat are sized such that a full cylinder's worth of water can be fed from the boiler/preheat coil combination. Without this the water filling the cylinder was not all at the same temperature and the group head temperature varied enough that it was necessary to temperature surf to get equivalent shot temperatures during back to back shots.
The dipper-stype Condor group has been modified by taking out the check valve ball and using a check valve in the line feeding the group from the brew boiler. In addition, the bottom two seals have been replaced by o-rings. This allows water to flow in and out of the group without pulling the lever because the only seal remains above the holes allowing water to fill the cylinder (just like the configuration of the LSM group). The o-rings fill the seal channels in the piston to reduce the amount of water required to fill the cylinder to a minimum.
A Matrix shower screen is used to prevent coffee solids from being allowed to reach the cylinder and piston when the pressure release solenoid is triggered.
A timer relay is used to keep the group fill solenoids just long enough to fill the group cylinder prior to releasing the lever. Because this is a dipper the preinfusion pressure is determined by the steam boiler temperature. Additional preinfusion pressure can be provided by controlling the raising of the lever when released.
- group head heated separately from boilers
- electronic control of when water flows to group
- pressure relief/shot stopper to end the shot when desired
This combination can make the modern hybrid lever work more like a modern saturated group espresso machine while keeping the essential characteristics of the classic lever espreso machine.
Here is a diagram showing how a hypothetical double boiler modern spring lever group espresso machine works. The Nurri, ACS, and others are likely to be similarly configured - I don't have access to any of them so I don't know for sure. The purpose of this is to describe how things can work and what is possible. Different machines may well have made different choices on how to provide similar capabilities.
The typical operation works by having movement of the lever and/or a manual switch trigger water flow into the group with a check valve holding the water in the group when the lever is released to allow the spring to start providing the shot pressure. When the shot is done a switch triggers the solenoid to release the pressure from the group and the water flows through an orifice that reduces the flow so that the lever doesn't move too flash and so it doesn't splash. Additional switches may be used to trigger water flow through the group or to the drip tray independantly of making a shot.
One innovative HB member came up with a method to modify a Strega to have a pressure release/shot stopper. Here is a diagram showing how I think a strega can be modified to operate similarly. The only changes required are adding the pressure release components. Here is a link: Bezzera Strega mods
Here is a diagram of BigEric's DIY Double Boiler Lever he recently built. While based on the hypothetical double boiler hybrid lever configuration it has further notable differences.
A gear pump controlled by a timer is used to control the volume of water being fed into the group cylinder. This allows for complete filling of the cylinder to ensure the largest possible shot volume and the highest possible spring pressure during the shot.
Incoming water is fed through a thermoblock to bring its temperature close to the brew boiler temperature then is fed into the brew boiler assembly which uses a coil wrapped around the boiler to dampen temperature fluctuations while the group cylinder fills. The volume of the boiler and preheat coil is sized to ensure that the water being fed into the full group cylinder is all the as close to the same temperature as possible.
An LSM group is used with modifications to initiate the timer when the group lever reaches the bottom of its travel. In addition, the internals of the preinfusion valve are removed to allow water flow to and from the group regardless of the position of the lever. The group head is heated by both cartridge heaters and a silicon band heater with a temperature sensor half-way up the group cylinder in order to reduce the temperature variations.
Here is a diagram of the current (and final?) configuration of my DIY Double Dipper Lever that now operates like a modern/hybrid lever. My goal was to be able to make each shot have the same temperature profile regardless of how much time had passed between the previous shot and the next. More specifcally, being able to make the next shot immediately after the prior shot with no temperature change has been my ultimate goal. There are some notable differences in my configuration.
Because the Condor group I used doesn't have a place for cartridge heaters I place them in a copper plate to which the group head is mounted. A band heater is installed around the group head bell to provide better heat control of the group head. I found that this was necessary to keep the group head temperature consistent from shot to shot. Without it the machine required an offset between the brew boiler and group head temperatures plus some amount of delay between shots for the group head to cool.
The brew boiler is fed by water from the steam boiler that has been mixed with line water to provide water that is a few degrees under the temperature of the brew boiler to ensure quick recovery without overshooting. This is done using the same mixing valve commonly used to control the temperature of the hot water tap on commercial espresso machines. The output of the mixing assembly goes into a preheat coil wound around the brew boiler then into the boiler to damp out changes in brew boiler temperature introduced by the incoming water. The volume of the brew boiler and preheat are sized such that a full cylinder's worth of water can be fed from the boiler/preheat coil combination. Without this the water filling the cylinder was not all at the same temperature and the group head temperature varied enough that it was necessary to temperature surf to get equivalent shot temperatures during back to back shots.
The dipper-stype Condor group has been modified by taking out the check valve ball and using a check valve in the line feeding the group from the brew boiler. In addition, the bottom two seals have been replaced by o-rings. This allows water to flow in and out of the group without pulling the lever because the only seal remains above the holes allowing water to fill the cylinder (just like the configuration of the LSM group). The o-rings fill the seal channels in the piston to reduce the amount of water required to fill the cylinder to a minimum.
A Matrix shower screen is used to prevent coffee solids from being allowed to reach the cylinder and piston when the pressure release solenoid is triggered.
A timer relay is used to keep the group fill solenoids just long enough to fill the group cylinder prior to releasing the lever. Because this is a dipper the preinfusion pressure is determined by the steam boiler temperature. Additional preinfusion pressure can be provided by controlling the raising of the lever when released.
Curtis
LMWDP #551
“Taste every shot before adding milk!”
LMWDP #551
“Taste every shot before adding milk!”
- baldheadracing
- Team HB
Looks good to me - although I wonder about the pressure release as a defining characteristic. For example, I don't think that the Marzocco Leva X has a pressure release, but it could be considered a modern machine.
I would consider making explicit the implied characteristic of user-adjustable controls for brew temperature profile via both boiler and grouphead heating elements. For example, I would not consider a stock Strega a hybrid lever for this reason.
I also wonder about double boilers being a characteristic, although you don't have this as a characteristic.
I would consider making explicit the implied characteristic of user-adjustable controls for brew temperature profile via both boiler and grouphead heating elements. For example, I would not consider a stock Strega a hybrid lever for this reason.
I also wonder about double boilers being a characteristic, although you don't have this as a characteristic.
-"Good quality brings happiness as you use it" - Nobuho Miya, Kamasada
I agree with you that the user adjustable temperature ability for the brew boiler and grouphead that are independent of each other is essential to the definition of the hybrid lever. I don't think the pressure release is necessary to qualify but I do believe the double boiler is also essential.
LMWDP #729
- pizzaman383 (original poster)
- Supporter ❤
You raise good points about the temperature management being crucial. There is a lot more going on with temperature management than it might seem. My goal was to reach similar temperature stability as a saturated group machine when I wanted it while also being able to make it operate like a classic lever when I wanted that.
The first challenge is feeding the group head with the same temperature water to fill the entire group cylinder. It took quite a bit of experimentation and measurements to find a way to prevent a temperature reduction when new water was entering the brew boiler. A tightly wrapped coil of tubing around the boiler takes the incoming water and that damps out the temperature drop of water inside the boiler while the group is filling.
The second challenge is the fact that the temperature of the group has a gradient from the bottom to the top. The piston, spring, and group casting bleed heat out the top because there is no water keeping them hot. There are also limited possible locations to feed heat into the group other than feeding it hot water.
The third challenge is that heating the group casting doesn't heat the piston and spring so that when hotter water hits it they immediately start pulling heat out of the water in the brew cylinder.
Adding a silicon band heater around the group head (again an innovation found by a fellow H-B member) helped with all these challenges.
The first challenge is feeding the group head with the same temperature water to fill the entire group cylinder. It took quite a bit of experimentation and measurements to find a way to prevent a temperature reduction when new water was entering the brew boiler. A tightly wrapped coil of tubing around the boiler takes the incoming water and that damps out the temperature drop of water inside the boiler while the group is filling.
The second challenge is the fact that the temperature of the group has a gradient from the bottom to the top. The piston, spring, and group casting bleed heat out the top because there is no water keeping them hot. There are also limited possible locations to feed heat into the group other than feeding it hot water.
The third challenge is that heating the group casting doesn't heat the piston and spring so that when hotter water hits it they immediately start pulling heat out of the water in the brew cylinder.
Adding a silicon band heater around the group head (again an innovation found by a fellow H-B member) helped with all these challenges.
Curtis
LMWDP #551
“Taste every shot before adding milk!”
LMWDP #551
“Taste every shot before adding milk!”
- pizzaman383 (original poster)
- Supporter ❤
Here is a picture of scace temperature testing of the current configuration of my DIY double dipper. The temperature setting you choose depends on whether you want to do a walk-up shot or are willing to do some fake shots to bring the temperature of the group head up. The shot stopper allows for less time between shots but also ends up giving a higher shot temperature.
Curtis
LMWDP #551
“Taste every shot before adding milk!”
LMWDP #551
“Taste every shot before adding milk!”
- pizzaman383 (original poster)
- Supporter ❤
I forgot to mention that with the fittings and tubing between the boiler and the group head there is a noticeable temperature drop between the boiler and the group head. It's necessary to either heat the fittings or plan for some offset. Heating them provides better repeatability because it reduces variation between shots that occur close in time.
Curtis
LMWDP #551
“Taste every shot before adding milk!”
LMWDP #551
“Taste every shot before adding milk!”
- BaristaBoy E61
How's about an active pump powered thermosiphon loop between the boiler and the group where the pump is PID controlled by a selectable ∆T.
That might bring a conventional group closer to that of a saturated group.
That might bring a conventional group closer to that of a saturated group.
"You didn't buy an Espresso Machine - You bought a Chemistry Set!"
- bostonbuzz
A more elegant temperature solution than wrapping a tube around the brew boiler is to use a HX in the steam boiler going to a mixing port which mixes HX hot water with cold water from the pump and the output of which feeds the brew boiler. This is the LM way and they have perfected it to the point of having minuscule cartridge-heated boilers in their Micra and Linea mini machines. That is even without a mixing valve to adjust how much of each water is mixed like in the gs3 and their other commercial machines.
I think if you do this solution you can use a tiny boiler. Actually, the large diameter tube-style HX of some machines can be made into a boiler if you can put all the fittings on one side (over temp safety button/temp probe/inlet/outlet on one side/low wattage heating element). You can mount it directly behind a heated grouphead and you will have perfect stability once you tune the hot water mix feeding it.
I.e.
You're describing a mod that coffeemachinist did using a silvia boiler http://coffeemachinist.com.au/andys-londinium/
I think if you do this solution you can use a tiny boiler. Actually, the large diameter tube-style HX of some machines can be made into a boiler if you can put all the fittings on one side (over temp safety button/temp probe/inlet/outlet on one side/low wattage heating element). You can mount it directly behind a heated grouphead and you will have perfect stability once you tune the hot water mix feeding it.
I.e.
You're describing a mod that coffeemachinist did using a silvia boiler http://coffeemachinist.com.au/andys-londinium/
LMWDP #353
I agree with you. As a next phase of improvement in my recently built double boiler lever, I'm going to experiment with and eventually move to a heat exchanger / cold water mixing approach. I'm currently not using the heat exchanger that's built into the steam boiler but will be able to experiment while keeping the lever working in its current configuration. To up the geek factor, I'm thinking of trying out having two gear pumps, one pushing the hot and one pushing the cold water, controlled by an Arduino to give ultimate adjustability and temperature control.
- pizzaman383 (original poster)
- Supporter ❤
Here is a link to BigEric's recent build
Modern DIY Double Boiler Lever Build
BTW BigEric and I are twins and have been collaborating on ideas for espresso machine builds for years.
Modern DIY Double Boiler Lever Build
BTW BigEric and I are twins and have been collaborating on ideas for espresso machine builds for years.
Curtis
LMWDP #551
“Taste every shot before adding milk!”
LMWDP #551
“Taste every shot before adding milk!”