No More Guesswork! Naked Truth of E61 Temperature Revealed

Need help with equipment usage or want to share your latest discovery?
User avatar
cannonfodder
Team HB
Posts: 8951
Joined: May 23rd, 2005

Postby cannonfodder » Jul 01, 2005, 11:05 pm

Word count: 1500
Agreement: I have read and agree to all the conditions of SwagFest 2005 ("the Contest").

No More Guesswork! Naked Truth of E61 Temperature Revealed
By Dave Stephens

'Help! My espresso tastes bitter/sour!' If I had a dollar for every time that appeared on an Internet forum, I would have a commercial espresso machine. There are numerous articles available on the Internet that discuss the importance of thermal stability. To achieve repeatable results, you must operate within the same temperature range and the initial extraction temperature should be within a degree. Without a reliable method of measuring that temperature it is just guesswork and sometimes bitter, other times sour shots of espresso.

For those of you that own an espresso machine with a heat exchanger, the key is the cooling flush (The best article I have come across on the subject is How I Stopped Worrying and Learned to Love HXs). If you are like me, you have searched the Internet, read every article about cooling flush timing, and intently stared at every graph you could find. Having assimilated all of this knowledge, you're surging with confidence that you can pull the elusive 'God Shot'. You power up your machine and let it heat. In anticipation, you stand there staring at it while pondering all of the knowledge you have gained. You think to yourself, 'I know my brew water needs to be between 195 and 205 degrees Fahrenheit', and then it hits you...

How the heck do I take its temperature?!?

The answer to that question is now at hand, at least for those of you that own an E61 group espresso machine. On the front of the group head is a single Allen screw. That screw plugs a hole that was drilled into the group to create the water channel that your brew water flows through. You can add an inexpensive thermometer through that screw and accurately measure your brew water temperature.

The process is not too difficult, but it does require the use of some power tools. For those of you with some moderate mechanical ability, this will be a relatively easy project. The best part is that it is cheap. The entire cost of goods (provided you already have the tools) is under $30 when using a digital thermometer.

You will need the following items...
    1. Probe thermometer or thermocouple
    2. Rotary tool (Dremel) with a cutoff wheel
    3. Hex head stainless steel bolt
    4. Drill bits and drill press
    5. High temperature torch and brazing rod
    6. Soldering pen and solder
    7. Heat shrink tubing
    8. Superglue
    9. Thermal grease.

Just screwing around...

Begin by removing the Allen screw from you brew group. Simply unscrew it with the appropriate sized Allen wrench. Next go to the hardware store and get a hex head bolt about twice the length of the original. Note that the bolt will be in direct contact with water, so be sure to get a stainless steel bolt. You could use aluminum or brass in a pinch (I find these harder to braze and although the soft metal is easier to drill, it also deforms more easily, especially under the heat of a torch; if possible stick with stainless steel), but do not use zinc-coated steel. The zinc bolts will rust! My Isomac uses an A6 size metric bolt but your machine may be different. Take the original with you to confirm the new bolt is the correct size.

Image

While at the store, you may want to pick up a couple extra cutoff wheels, they have a tendency to break at the worst time. You can get the thermal grease at almost any electronic/computer store. I picked my tube up at Radio Shack. If you ask for thermal grease and get a blank stare, try asking for heat sync grease.

Nurse, scalpel please...

Clamp your probe thermometer down to your work surface. I used a piece of two by six and a rubber-padded clamp.

Image

Using the cutoff wheel on your rotary tool, gently cut a grove down the probe housing. This takes a bit of finesse, if you dwell in one spot too long the cutting wheel will heat the probe and burn the wires and sensor inside. Grind one spot for only one or two seconds working your way down the length of the probe. You do not need to cut completely through, just enough to form a crack. Remember to leave two inches at the bottom of the probe uncut. This will become the insert for the bolt and where you reassemble and attach the thermometer display.

Image

Now loosen your clamp and rotate the probe 180 degrees. Clamp it back down and repeat the process. Make two additional cuts, one at both end of the probe housing to bisect the previous cuts. Then gently pry the two halves apart using a small screwdriver or similar tool. Don't be surprised if you have to lightly grind one or two spots so the parts can separate.

Image

Now that it is open, you can see the lead wires that run to the thermal sensor at the end of the probe. Be very careful, the sensor is very small and very fragile; if you tug too hard on those wires, you can separate them from the sensor.

Now remove the probe display from the lead wires and the display base from the probe. I simply cut the base in half using the rotary tool and snipped the probe wires with a pair of small wire cutters. Gently remove the sensor and lead wires from the housing and set everything to the side.

Now you can cut the end of the probe housing off. Do not cut it too short, remember this has to go through the bolt and the display has to be glued back onto it during the final assembly.

Image

Time to drill...

You will need to drill a hole the same diameter as the probe through the center of your bolt. You want a tight fit. Remember this is going back into the brew path where it will be subjected to 9 bar pressure (about 130 PSI).

Center punch the bolt, mount it in a vice on your drill press and drill a hole the entire length of the bolt.

Image

Test fit the probe in the bolt. You need the end of the probe to protrude about 1/8 to 1/4 inch beyond the end of the bolt. If the bolt is too long, cut it down with your rotary tool and cutoff wheel or grind it down with a bench grinder. If you have to shorten the bolt, try screwing it into your machine to make sure you did not damage the threads. You may have to run a die over the end of the bolt to re-cut the first thread.

Image

Fire and molten metal, sounds like fun...

Now we need to braze the probe body into the bolt. Using your torch, heat the hex head end of the bolt and apply your brazing material to seal any gaps. My braze is not the best looking but I am not a professional welder. An acetylene torch is ideal for this. You could also take the bolt and probe housing to a welding shop and have them braze it together for you.

Image

Glue the base of the probe display back onto the shaft and let it dry.

Trim the lead wires for the thermal sensor if needed. Once you have cut the leads to the appropriate length, slide the heat shrink tubing down the leads. Solder the probe display back on. Slide your shrink tube over the solder joint and heat it to shrink.

Image

Apply some thermal grease to the thermal sensor and gently insert it down to the bottom of the probe tube. Snap the display back together and test it to make sure everything works correctly.

Image
Greased up...

Image
and assembled.

Leak test...

Apply a liberal amount of Teflon tape to the bolt and screw it back into the machine. Once you try to screw it back into your espresso machine you will understand why I recommended a hex head bolt. You can use an open-end wrench to screw it back into the group head opening.

Power on your espresso machine and run a water flush through it. Take a portafilter and a blank basket (back flush basket) and lock it onto you machine. Hit your brew lever and let the brew group pressurize; check for leaks. I would recommend pressure testing your new creation prior to the boiler hitting full temp. Getting sprayed by a stream of 80 degree water is much less damaging than a shot of water from a 250 degree boiler. Be careful.

Image
Leak test at LOW temp.

Life! Give my creation LIFE!

Go ahead and let your machine warm up and start your espresso routine.

Image
Temperature at the start of the shot

Image
Temperature at the end of the shot

Want to see it in action? Watch the video. Now you will never have to guess about what your brew temperature is. You are one step closer to consistency and that elusive 'God Shot'.

Assi
Posts: 1
Joined: February 18th, 2007

Postby Assi » Feb 18, 2007, 8:15 pm

Hi,
I think this is a must device if you dont have a PID
I was wondering if you can build one for me too? I own an Isomac TEA
I dont have the right tools and hands to make a device like this ;-)
Please let me know how much you want for something like that.
Thanks,
Assi

User avatar
HB
Admin
Posts: 17019
Joined: April 29th, 2005

Postby HB » Feb 18, 2007, 8:57 pm

Eric has developed turnkey solutions, one using a thermocouple and the other using a thermometer like Dave's. See Monitoring Brew Temperature - E61 & Silvia or email Eric for details.
Dan Kehn

User avatar
cannonfodder
Team HB
Posts: 8951
Joined: May 23rd, 2005

Postby cannonfodder » Feb 18, 2007, 10:27 pm

Eric's adapter is a better option, cleaner and more accurate if you go with the thermocouple version.
Dave Stephens

Spresso_Bean
Posts: 215
Joined: March 20th, 2007

Postby Spresso_Bean » Jul 07, 2008, 8:07 pm

I'm coming into this thread a bit late, but would something ready-made like this sensor from Auber work as another inexpensive option for monitoring temp on an E61 machine? It could be connected to a multimeter or a PID as a temp display, and it's an M6 bolt but I don't know for sure if there's something else I'm missing such as thread pitch, length, etc. I just thought maybe someone could tell from their description if it would fit an Expobar Pulser for example. Eric S's adaptor is nice but it's a little more than I'd like to spend at the moment on just the adaptor. Thanks for any comments and advice.

http://auberins.com/index.php?main_page=product_info&cPath=3&products_id=6
LMWDP #200

ciaocaffe
Posts: 17
Joined: July 5th, 2008

Postby ciaocaffe » Jul 07, 2008, 9:00 pm

Very interesting! I literally just asked this question to the nice Auberins company early this morning.

But that link the previous poster referred to is not the one I was asking about. That one uses a thread pitch screw of 1.25mm - wouldn't work.

Here's the one I was curious about
http://auberins.com/index.php?main_page=product_info&cPath=3&products_id=2

And I'm well aware it would need to be brazed or JB Welded.

It wouldn't be per se an alternative to Eric's as that one is able to be more user friendly with install and removal. This would just be a cheaper, easier, alternative.

For someone on a budget, go to Auberins, buy a decent PID for a good cost, buy that 6ft K Type thermocouple that has the M6, 1mm screw, braze or JB Weld it, install and hook up to the PID.

My only concern was the length of it. Would it be long enough to get a decent reading. I would think so as cannonfodder's homemade device indicates just letting the probe extend a bit beyond the screw end.
I'll have to look back to his instructions.

Yeah, so that's quite the coincidence previous poster asking just as I asked early this morning to Auberins. :P

Well, either way, it'd be nice to hear from someone. Most likely I'll be ordering anyway for the heck of it. Sure want to get a PID at least.

Also, found some METRIC OmegaLok compression fittings just like Eric's from Swagelok for $15 SS.
Now THAt would be a lower cost alternative and still be in the same class.
I'm waiting to hear back from them in regards to the M6, 1mm end. But they do have METRIC in stock at least. It's getting close.

Sorry, I'm on a tight budget and just can't swing $71 for an adaptor, nor want to go with brass, besides, it's getting real close that such a compression fitting is already available elsewhere for $15.
Hey, don't get me wrong, I really appreciate Eric's passion and efforts and what he has contributed, it's just that money is a key factor for many and if there is an equal item out there, well, it'd be nice for the people that can't afford $71 to be able to explore the same joys.

Spresso_Bean
Posts: 215
Joined: March 20th, 2007

Postby Spresso_Bean » Jul 07, 2008, 9:10 pm

Yeah Eric's adaptor seems to be top notch, but for me it's also about the cost of it right now. As far as brazing or JB Weld, is that because the Auber sensors aren't water tight or something?
LMWDP #200

ciaocaffe
Posts: 17
Joined: July 5th, 2008

Postby ciaocaffe » Jul 07, 2008, 9:41 pm

They indicated in their reply email that the thermocouple does not have a "liquid tight seal", that the screw and thermocouple are two separate pieces.

Hey, that's fine. As long as the screw is the same size, I'm plenty up for brazing (with special acid flux for SS) or JB Welding. The niceness of all of this would be not having to drill a screw yourself. Not everyone has a lathe and it's not too fun drilling through stainless.

So, that's all I really got for a reply from Auber. They indicate the screw is the size it is, so what more can they say. The specs show a match.
I think for people not looking for anal .1 precision and not graphing this stuff - only using as a general guide when to pull their shots - this thermocouple could work well for the $7. The depth may be off, but I still think it shouldn't be too bad. Maybe the probe can be pushed down a bit more.
The main thing is the screw fitting in.

Like I said, most likely I'll probably ordering one and report back later.

I'm still curious, like with cannonfodder's device at the opening of this thread, when screwing down a bolt headed screw to the e61 grouphead, what do you do when you get near the surface of the GH as your tightening? Won't the bolt head scratch the surface? If you don't let it touch the surface, then how does it tighten down? Very curious about this!

At least with a compression fitting like OmegaLok's, there's the rounded raised area as spacing.

User avatar
erics
Posts: 6023
Joined: August 9th, 2005

Postby erics » Jul 07, 2008, 10:36 pm

I'm not always the bearer of bad news but . . .

The thermocouples from Auber Instruments are NOT suitable for installation in a pressurized environment. They are really designed for use in a thermowell. The threads on ALL of them have an OD of 0.241" and a thread pitch of 20 threads per inch which is fairly close to a thread spacing of 1.25 mm.

The Omegalok fittings whether they be US sized or metric sized all have pipe threads on the end. These pipe threads can be NPT, BSP, or BSPP per your specs when you order. They MAY make one with M6 x 1.00 threading but that would be custom ($).

Edit 7/8/08 - I was wrong by saying that all of Auber Instruments thermocouples have the thread as described. In fact, he does have thermocouples with an M6 x 1.00 thread but all other comments still apply.
Skål,

Eric S.
http://users.rcn.com/erics/
E-mail: erics at erols dot com

User avatar
mhoy
Posts: 1126
Joined: January 9th, 2008

Postby mhoy » Jul 07, 2008, 10:57 pm

I've a thermocouple that came with my Anita and it's suppose to fit a E61 group head. Anyone know the heritage or does Omega really supply these??? I'm trying to remember what the guy I bought it from said, but I can't recall. I'll be selling it since I now use my Elektra T1 daily. :D (I've a 36 gauge thermocouple for the Elektra, but that will be a different thread).

Image

Mark

 
Sponsored by counterculturecoffee.com
www.counterculturecoffee.com: coffee driven people, people driven coffee