Vibiemme Domobar Junior HX New Digital Edition vs Rancilio Siliva Pro X

Recommendations for buyers and upgraders from the site's members.
JesperT

#1: Post by JesperT »

Following extensive research to acquire a more serious espresso machine I was just about to buy the new Rancilio Siliva Pro X, a quality dual boiler machine that lets you steam and brew at the same time. Speaking to a sales advisor on the phone and with no way of a real life try-out, he suggested that the Vibiemme Junior HX was a far superior in terms build and a better machine overall. There is not a whole lot of documentation to be found on the internet and I would like to hear suggestions of why I should or should not go for the Vibiemme. The Silvia Pro X doesnt seem complicated to use and if used correctly should make a great espresso everytime without much technical wizadry. It is important the machines milk steamer is top notch for lattes etc.

Does anyone have suggestions/experience here?

Muche appreciated. Jesper

Satchmo780

#2: Post by Satchmo780 »

Vibiemme makes quality machines, but for me I would go with the double boiler over the HX. The HX will have some temp management issues with an E61 grouphead for multiple shots.

Rancilio build quality is also excellent, so I wouldn't be concerned about that.
LMWDP #737

JesperT (original poster)

#3: Post by JesperT (original poster) »

Thanks for the sound advice Alex, yes, the dual boiler feature weighs heavy in the decision. I suppose there is not much to it in terms of the actual brew quality?

User avatar
Jeff
Team HB

#4: Post by Jeff »

Welcome to H-B

I'd spend some time and read here about choices in your budget. I don't know prices in your area, but I suspect there are machines to consider that can provide either or both better usability or results in the cup, especially if you explore light-roast espresso.

Satchmo780

#5: Post by Satchmo780 »

JesperT wrote:Thanks for the sound advice Alex, yes, the dual boiler feature weighs heavy in the decision. I suppose there is not much to it in terms of the actual brew quality?
If you're in London - I would try going out and finding a few machines to try. I think most machines above the $1k price range will provide a good quality brew, given the operator knows a few basics. I think the Silvia Pro would be more consistent for espresso because you have less temperature management issues, but that's not to say that an HX system won't provide good espresso.
LMWDP #737

JesperT (original poster)

#6: Post by JesperT (original poster) »

Thanks. I've yet to find a retailer to demo the Silvia Pro X or similar domestic machines in that price range. Perhaps you could recommend where to go in London?

BodieZoffa

#7: Post by BodieZoffa »

JesperT wrote:Following extensive research to acquire a more serious espresso machine I was just about to buy the new Rancilio Siliva Pro X, a quality dual boiler machine that lets you steam and brew at the same time. Speaking to a sales advisor on the phone and with no way of a real life try-out, he suggested that the Vibiemme Junior HX was a far superior in terms build and a better machine overall. There is not a whole lot of documentation to be found on the internet and I would like to hear suggestions of why I should or should not go for the Vibiemme. The Silvia Pro X doesnt seem complicated to use and if used correctly should make a great espresso everytime without much technical wizadry. It is important the machines milk steamer is top notch for lattes etc.

Does anyone have suggestions/experience here?

Muche appreciated. Jesper
Never used a Vibiemme machine and imagine the build quality/performance is top notch, but a 'sales advisor' is doing just that, trying to sell you what they are pushing. I personally never read into what others find to be the 'best' as it's entirely subjective and the only one that will ever know what's best for you is YOU. The 2 machines you ask about are drastically different, but I can vouch for the Silvia Pro as it's what you would expect... a rock solid performer with a simple industrial/raw design that gives fantastic consistency in a predictable manner. Might not have the constantly touted 'cutting edge' features, but simply doesn't need them for what it's meant to do.

JesperT (original poster)

#8: Post by JesperT (original poster) »

Thank you Bodie. You are confirming my hunch and think I will go for the Silvia Pro X. Much appreciated!