Versalab M4 - Alternatives

Recommendations for buyers and upgraders from the site's members.
macaber8

#1: Post by macaber8 »

Hello,

Thanks to a forum member, I was introduced to Versalab M4. I found it amazing that this grinder seems to produce a well in the middle after the grind naturally. Also, they claim you dont need WDT with this grinder.

I love everything about this machine except the price tag. Is there other grinder that can achieve similar result? well in the middle and no WDT needed?

I think a well in the middle will help slow down donut extraction even when grind is finer at higher dosage. Essentially, this is to intentionally distribute more grounded coffee to the side such that the entire puck will have even flowrate when pressure is applied.

Any input is appreciated.

uncola

#2: Post by uncola »

Hedone honne perhaps?

User avatar
RTOBarista
Supporter ♡

#3: Post by RTOBarista »

I almost got the Hendone espresso grinder. Then I ordered the Option O P64. A Titus Espresso grinder became available and bought it and cancelled my P64

Kafetek keeps on changing and their Shurikone burrs (two step grinding) are similar to the DRM burrs of Versalab, Hedone and Titus.

Review sounds too good to be true
https://coffeetime.freeflarum.com/blog/ ... ugust-2022
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3pMXfqLd ... 1q8&t=107s
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZoEZeirQ7RQ Workflow of Hendone seems more than the Versalab or Titus

This is probably a good option and will not change for sometime.

Titus with shipping, customs, US power supply( ordered in US), and dosing funnel was $9266

macaber8 (original poster)

#4: Post by macaber8 (original poster) »

uncola wrote:Hedone honne perhaps?
Am I tripping or Versalab M4 ($3,365) and Honne (home version 1500 Euro = $1,603.68) are identical grinders? With Honne being half price, both runs at 500 rpm, conical burr pre grind to a flat burr. How is versalab even survive?

User avatar
Jake_G
Team HB

#5: Post by Jake_G »

They survive because their small customer base see Hedone for what it very legitimately appears to be (an unscrupulous copy shop, with zero respect for anyone's IP) and say, "Thanks, but no thanks".

Without original products coming from original designers and manufacturers, the clones never exist. And so, when you support the clones to save a buck (or a few thousand), you kill the engine that fuels innovation and you're left with milquetoast copies of the same thing, in perpetuity.

Their espresso machines are also blatant copies/mutant children of Kees/Slayer/LM machines. They are cheap. But they are riding on the coat tails of those actually doing innovation and then undercutting them. It's tough.

Frank Durra could be seen as a similar story, but his business model actually began with taking individual VL grinders that were basically unusable back in the early days and would modify them with meaningful upgrades that improved their performance on an individual basis. That is, Laura and John (Versalab) got money for the original grinder purchase and then the owner sent the grinder to Frank for modifications. Eventually, so much of the grinder was changed through his mods that he began building the original TITVS grinders from scratch, cutting out VL.

He also makes upgrade parts for Slayer espresso machines and EK43 grinders, and of course has released several new and novel grinders of the last few years, so I see Frank as a completely different business model than Hedone, but it could be that I'm just salty as an engineer/designer when I see copycats undercut the original designers.

Maybe I would feel different if the Honne were $4,000 or $5,000? Hard to say, but that's why I won't be buying any if their products...
LMWDP #704
★ Helpful

Quester

#6: Post by Quester »

macaber8 wrote:I think a well in the middle will help slow down donut extraction even when grind is finer at higher dosage.
Slight donut extractions may be a good thing, because the edges are often under extracted because of the fluid dynamics of the basket.
Jake_G wrote:Without original products coming from original designers and manufacturers, the clones never exist. And so, when you support the clones to save a buck (or a few thousand), you kill the engine that fuels innovation and you're left with milquetoast copies of the same thing, in perpetuity.
There's also the support side. I had to send my Versalab back to John in New Mexico for a tweak. He responded immediately, and returned my grinder within a week.

There's also something cool about using a grinder that helped lead the way in single dosing. It's satisfying.

Pressino

#7: Post by Pressino »

Quester wrote:Slight donut extractions may be a good thing, because the edges are often under extracted because of the fluid dynamics of the basket.
This is a very good point and should be repeated whenever folks mention, as frequently occurs in HB forum discussions, that "donut extraction" is somehow detrimental and needs to be prevented from happening. The video of the Hendone shows an initial donut extraction, as do in fact most of the videos of we have of naked extractions.

I understand the thinking behind the idea that donut extraction somehow reflects "imperfect" extraction due to less-than-ideal water flow through the puck. The thinking may be correct but may (likely does) fail to account for all the variables that go into making good espresso. I've been aware for quite a while of arguments that donut extraction is somehow detrimental. Initially I felt anxiety that I needed to "fix" this problem and fretted over ways to do so (including changing baskets)...but soon came to the conclusion that my shots were pretty darned good and weren't getting any better, so I decided to let my extraction OCD anxiety go and enjoy the Zen of guilt-free coffee enjoyment. :)

macaber8 (original poster)

#8: Post by macaber8 (original poster) »

I agree. I think I'm at the same place.

If it is a regular basket, I would want some donut effect since usually outside is under extracted.

With the new holes to the edge billet baskets, I'm think donut effect is working against us again.

macaber8 (original poster)

#9: Post by macaber8 (original poster) »

Hedone honne:
Only have 220V option and only work for 58mm portafilter. Ship to US west coast is about $300. We need transformer.

Versalab M4 is not that much more expensive once all Included. Plus, Versalab is in US, easier to service for me.