Ah - I feel your pain!! It took me a long time to re-teach myself to make foam from an Andreja Premium after having made it so easily with a Silvia. And complain as I might, to Chris, to folks here, and to others - it was always me saying that the king had no clothes! I looked into getting an after-market three or four-hole tip to replace the huge double-holed tip of the Andreja, but to no avail - I'd have had to replace the entire arm and I didn't want to do that.
Of course none of that helps you to make foam. The short answer is - you just have to re-learn how to make foam with an enormous amount of steam power. I practiced with, and still use, a small 10-ounce SS pitcher trying over and over again to get microfoam until I finally conquered the sucker. I can tell you how I do it but you'll have to forget what you did on the Silvia and simply re-learn, using this machine.
I don't measure the temperature anymore so I can't give you exact numbers but basically, I do the following (in my case, with 2% organic milk although it's easier with whole milk). It sounds like this is what you're doing but obviously it isn't:
- cool the milk in the fridge (I don't use the freezer and this works even if the milk is warm)
- blow out the water in the steam wand with a few short blasts
- lean the wand arm on the inside of the spout using it as a kind of guide and bury the wand deep in the milk, turning it up to max. You don't need to open the valve all the way - just a turn or two.
- oh-so-slowly lower the pitcher until the tip gets near the surface and that unmistakable "tearing" sound is heard. This is the most critical part and from your description, it sounds like this is where it's not happening for you. It sounds like you're not getting the microfoam.
- watch the level of the surface rise - in my case the foaming causes it to rise about 3/4 inch and the outside of the pitcher feels "warm".
- bury the wand and find an angle in order to make sure that the milk is swirling around. When the outside upper part of the pitcher is too hot to touch, you're done.
- bang the pitcher a time or three to get rid of the bubbles and swirl the milk in the pitcher to circulate the foam evenly throughout the pitcher.
- pour...
No good? - Try again (or ask more questions)!!

I know it seems impossible now but if you work at it, it will happen.
BobY