UFGators wrote: I was a bit nervous when I saw the wood stuck up in the holes (I bet it is near irreversable),
When I started doing this, I was just as worried. It was simply going to be a stop-gap measure until I got the new tip and drilled my own holes in it (I had a FIVE-holer for a twelve ounce pitcher with three or three-and-a-half ounces of milk...). It worked so well though, that over a year later, that pristine new no-hole tip is still in my drawer.
If you want to remove the toothpick bits, simply unscrew your tip, and push the pointy bits out from the inside. It really is too easy, so you can stop worrying!