I purchased a Gaggia Classic and Baby Mazzer a couple weeks ago, then just received my first order from counter culture (espresso toscana). I have a bottomless PF coming this week, which I am eagerly awaiting.
There are so many variables in extracting a good shot I thought I'd list the tips and techniques which had the most significant impact to me. I'm not including the importance of a good grinder, which I can easily confirm is paramount to a good shot. In any event, I'd highly suggest you learn these things first, rather than putting it off until you figure out that you cannot pull a consistently good shot.
1. Dosing. Use a scale and use the technique of smoothing the coffee around the edges of the PF. Note that I don't really do anything fancy--just kind of level it with my index finger, ensuring there's a "seal" around all the edges before tamping.
2. The Grind. Time your extractions to help with identifying when blonding is occurring. If you're like me, you're having a hard time determining when to stop the shot b/c when the stream goes blond is kind of subjective as well as hard to see under the machine (I still use a flashlight). So if you time your extraction precisely at 25 seconds and, once you see and taste your shot, it's overextracted (and it's more volume than it "should" be) adjust your grind to a little more finer grind, or vice versa. Here's where a good grinder with infinite adjustments will really help you out.
3. Tamping. I was over-tamping at first, I guess because I like to prove my manliness to a hunk of metal
4. Coffee. Once you can get a good shot consistently, buy good coffee from a good roaster like http://www.counterculture.com. It will open up a whole new side of coffee you never knew existed. Imagine reading the taste description on their site, buying and extracting that blend, then being able to taste all those things they mention. Even "good" local roasters in Austin over-roast and the coffee loses its complexity and distinction. For me, it was always, "light" or "dark"--with no real interesting flavors showing through. The difference is like going from Budlight to a Miller Lite versus a micro-brew IPA to a Porter then a wheat.
All the other tips, like changing one variable at a time, are obviously crucial. Maybe that should have been my #1.
Thanks again, and I'd appreciate any more tips as well as corrections / clarifications to what I've newbily written. Jack




