by orphanespresso on Tue Aug 04, 2009 5:18 pm
Interesting observation about those Mcal seals. Both the manufacturer supplied Mcal and PV seals are REALLY hard and unforgiving. We have a lot of seals made from Viton (very stretchy with a durometer rating of 70, which is as hard as one can get in Viton) and EPDM rubber (also stretchy at a durometer of 80, once again max duro for this type of seal). Both of these materials make a seal that is easy to install and seals fine, lasts as long oas the OEM seals....but those factory seals are like rocks....very difficult to istall, real hand crampers and generally one gets tempted to use two awls to intall them, and when they roll in the piston groove they are hard to maneuver into the right position. I had not thought that they could be some composite but that would make sense in explaining the hardness and lack of elasticity. I had assumed that the factory rubbers were simply stale, likely having been jobbed out in some huge quantity and as they age they get stiffer.
The catch with the Mcal rubbers is that they are the only source for those two sided bottom W seals that fit the Mcal and a couple other machines, but if it is the upper V profile seal some other could be used, with some shims in the groove to snug it all up. That is , if it is only the upper seal that is causing the problems. You could even resort to a high temp silicone O ring for the upper, along with some shimming with teflon or silicone tape, or go custom with both seals using silicone, but it wouldn't be factory.