www.baratza.com: skilled in the art of grinding

Do Some Coffees Have Silent First Crack? - Page 2

Postby another_jim on Sat Dec 18, 2010 5:58 pm

According to the research, the first crack is caused by high pressure steam escaping the bean. Water escapes before the first crack, as the bean dries, but in liquid/vapor form; until the cell walls crack, the pressure is so high inside them, that steam only forms around 350F.

If the coffee is past crop, very dry and with cracked cell walls, the first crack won't happen at all. On the M3, open the trap door when the bean temp thermometer reads 150C and sniff -- a wet grassy haze should be coming off the beans. If it's dry and smoky, you have past crop beans.

The first crack will be weak and late if the coffee is dry, even if it is new. Naturals and pulp naturals tend to have quieter and later first cracks -- whether this is the processing itself or longer delays in shipping, I don't know.

As far as I can tell, a weak first crack doesn't usually mean you can improve the roast by going faster. If the coffee is past crop, it may even hurt; since old coffees need to be roasted at lower temperatures. If the coffee is not past crop, the usual indicator of a too slow roast, a flat, dull taste, is more diagnostic than the cracks.
User avatar
another_jim
Team HB
 
Posts: 7489
Joined: May 05, 2005
Location: Chicago

Postby benm5678 on Sat Dec 18, 2010 7:21 pm

Thanks for your replies! I tried this coffee today, 6 days past roast, and it wasn't amazing. Had to set the grind a lot finer than I'm used to. Not a lot of dry aroma. Shots eventually pulled nice, and taste not horrific, but not much flavor... kinda blah... I may need to experiment more though with temps etc. I was on the low side. Very dry leathery mouth feel. Only got 2# of it so no biggie if doesn't work...

Fullsack wrote:Try shortening your time to the first, a faster ramp using more temperature early on and see if that changes anything, ~12-15F/min seems a little slow

It did have a quicker roast finish than I try to shoot for espresso, so that's why I thought If I'd come in with a faster ramp, it'd be even quicker... but the ramp stage did take bit longer than I usually like, so maybe I do need higher heat in the middle, and cut it as 1C starts. Will try again and see... (graph of this roast shown below)

another_jim wrote:open the trap door when the bean temp thermometer reads 150C and sniff -- a wet grassy haze should be coming off the beans. If it's dry and smoky, you have past crop beans.

Thanks a lot for the great tip, I will sniff it next time ;)

Image
User avatar
benm5678
 
Posts: 202
Joined: Aug 13, 2008
Location: earth

Postby Fullsack on Sat Dec 18, 2010 7:42 pm

If the 8:02 first crack didn't make it happen, then I'm sure Jim is correct. It is the probably the age green coffee. The necessity of a very fine grind isn't usually a good sign.
Doug Jamieson
http://www.fullsackjack.com/
LMWDP #017

Oh yeah, it's deliziosa!
User avatar
Fullsack
 
Posts: 767
Joined: Aug 05, 2006
Location: San Francisco

Previous

Return to Home Roasting