RMH-
First things first- Welcome aboard...!
Second things second- "Where ever you go, there you are" Buckaroo Bonzai stated it" No matter where you go- Therer ya are!"- - so you and he must be , uh, cousins?

A great line BTW!
Third things third- We have all gotten excited about being resourceful. And I say this with caution , so as not to throw water on your campfire and all, but we ALL need to be careful and remember not to use materials that might not be "food safe" for gasket materials. I for one , have done so, recommended so and through the wisdom of others, say ,
TUS172,...... lead me to understand the error of my "excitable" ways.. I then saw the light that I missed while I was busy being resourceful
So you have done a great job- ! Another good foodsafe option is getting a standard La Pavoni flat boiler gasket (cheap ) and then trace your element flange on to it and use the hole punch exactly as you did.
But since you went to all the trouble of joining and all , and chose a name and have a good signature line and such-- we would like to keep you around and not have to refer to you as the new guy whose puck is not quite tamped all the way any more since he got that new boiler gasket--
So check it out- and remember this is all stated with watching out for a possible new LMWDP member..