If it didn't used to do it, now does, and you're approaching your shots the same way - is it possible that there is something wrong with the machine? Bad heating element, poor seals etc.
Well, thats the crux of the issue. I'm still new to this machine and I may very well have picked up a bad habit or two while trying to adapt to it.
However, I can't see it being a problem with the machine. Its job is to make hot water and it does that. My first thought was that the temperature was too low, but I'm now thinking that this is not the case as the resulting first (good) shot is almost too hot to drink.

First shot on the right, second on the left.