by another_jim on Wed Sep 07, 2005 5:45 pm
After spending 4 years, 24/7 operation, with a Mater pressurestat, I can definitely say the sticky diaphragm is not a sign of a failing stat. Mine got stuck in the first few months after I bought the machine. The spare I bought on the occasion is quietly gathering dust, and a couple of times a year I unstick the original stat.
There's good news and bad news:
The good news is that the diaphragm is made of aluminum and simply does not fail -- these stats wear out when the microswitch fails either because of electrical load in a few years (if it's switching the boiler direct) or mechanical failure after a decade (if it's only switching an SSR).
The bad news is that the diaphragm sticks in the "heat on" position. This happens mostly new out of the box, on start up, or in a few hours after, since the diaphragm has had time to freeze in the "on" position. This happens regardless of the stats age; and we have lots of stories of people ordering new ones after an old one sticks and getting the same thing when they started the machine up. This means your safety valve will occasionally get a work out, and you'll get a heart stress test when the machine starts blowing steam. If your heart can't take the stress, get a Sirai and replace it every few years.
You unstick the diaphragm by removing the adjustment screw and working the pin under it in and out with a needle nose pliers. When you hear the micro-switch click back and forth, it's unstuck.
Jack Denver of alt.coffee, who I respect, says the steam side of the aluminum can get slightly oxidized, so that it helps to dunk the stat in lemon juice once a year or so to polish up the diaphragm. The bellows on mine get flooded when I descale, so I've been doing this a couple of times a year willy-nilly. For me the freeze up happens only a few times a year on average, so I'm not sure how big a difference it makes.
On the Ceme, the adjustment screw threads are extremely fragile, so careful. Many people have given up on the Ceme's deadband adjustment, since it doesn't seem to make much difference. Apparently, the newest Ceme models do not have this, and are set on the tightest band possible (around 0.1 bar). The Maters seem to run at 0.15 to 0.2; the Sirais at 0.3 to 0.4 bar.
In any case, these small pressurestats are better performers when used in conjunction with an interposing relay or SSR, than the Sirais, since they have tighter deadbands and a wider adjustment range. LM uses them on their non-electronic steam boilers; so the hobbyist knock on them is simply garbage.