erics wrote:A diagram from you might be helpful because it is hard to interpret "moves slightly down".
The diagram of the E61 parts in the brew position may be helpful:
From Is there a purpose for the E61 middle brew lever position?When the lever is in the brew position, allowing water to enter the chamber, the leading lobe of the cam shown above is
just past the stem that lifts the upper valve. That is, the cam/spring-loaded stem naturally act as a detent. It should not take much resistance to hold the lever in the upper detent position, since it's already held fairly snug in its travel by the sealing O-rings for the cam shaft connected to the lever itself.
Ron didn't mention the age of this machine, but a worn upper stem (#16), worn cam (#6), or weakening upper valve closure spring (#18) could result in less staying power for the lever.
E61 Group Espresso Machine: Detailed Interior Schematics and the original E61 patent diagram will make these parts references clearer:
From The E61 Group - Truth and LiesCoffeetime's
How to Lubricate Your E61 Group includes some nice photos and notes a common sign of valve lifter wear is that the lever sometimes drops down on its own when pulling a shot.