Earlier, you had said:
When I powered the machine up, the pump engaged without me hitting the brew switch and water came out the OPV valve.
That tells me that the OPV has failed in some manner. The impression you have in your rubber valve face is normal - very similar to the impression that is shown in this steam valve face:

In your case, it is the impression of the valve seat which is inside the large hexagonal body at the threaded end. It is entirely possible that the seat is slightly damaged or there is a piece of "whoknowswhat" on the seat. Because the movement of this valve during normal operation or during blind filter operation is VERY SMALL (about a tenth of an inch at the very most), it doesn't take much to upset operation.