Everman wrote:I know I could just throw in a new pump and be done with it but I'm wondering if I should make a small project of it and put in a rotary.
A rotary pump is quiet, but it pressurizes much more quickly, so you'll lose a small degree of progressive preinfusion;
Pressure profiles, preinfusion and the forgiveness factor elaborates on this point. The difference is probably negligible for an E61 with an expansion chamber (Levetta), but may be noticeable for an E61 with solenoid (Valentina).
La Valentina (left) and the Levetta (right)A rotary pump + motor would be a
very tight fit in your espresso machine's casing. I agree with duke-one that the fitting of an externally mounted pump would be less complicated. If your main motivation is quiet operation, you could "outboard" the vibratory pump. That's what I did and it was whisper quiet:
