HB wrote:You're not the only one! I reviewed the Gaggia New Baby for WIRED magazine; it sells for $399 full retail, but is frequently on sale for less (e.g., WholeLatteLove has it for $299 at this moment). I'd take the $400 saved over a Rancilio Silvia and put it towards the grinder (or a gift for a loved one). Or, as you noted, the Rancilio Silvia + PID combination is within striking distance of an entry-level HX espresso machine if you've already got budget for a good grinder.
I think it might be a bit of a different situation in Canada. The Gaggia Baby can be found for around $450 ($499 full retail), while the CC1 is $699. The Vario wasn't on sale with the Gaggia, so the choice between Gaggia + Vario for $900 or CC1 + Vario for $1050 was pretty easy for me. The price difference between the Silvano and the CC1 is a lot more in Canada too - it's $1099 around here, so with the Vario it would have been $1550.
Had I been in the states, where the price difference between the CC1 and the Silvano is smaller, I might have gotten the Silvano, as it seems more robust (and prettier) than the CC1. However, for me, $1050 for the CC1 + Vario was the sweet spot, and I'm quite happy with it! I think the temperature control alone makes it worth the extra $150 over the Gaggia.



