The_Left_Hand wrote:Please correct me if I'm misguided here:
I've been thinking lately that I would love to have more temperature control with my newly acquired Chemex; here's the strategy I've adopted ...
Prepare three cups, two with the old style brew, and one with the new. Then try them blind. If you can pick out the new one and prefer it, you method is worthwhile. If you can't, then it isn't.
My own experience in triangle tests is that there is a surprising level of variation and inconsistency in even identically brewed cups, so that the experimental cup has to be very different for it to reliably stand out. Based on this, I think all these attempts at brewing more precisely and painstakingly are going in the wrong direction. For uniform cups, I think it may be best to have an instrument that provides a real time solids extraction readout, and to end brewing the moment it hits its target. This closed loop, solids extraction based brewer can brew sloppily, but will always produce a uniform brew.
The analogy is pouring a cup full of water. If you can see, you don't need precise flow control or timing, you just need to stop when the cup is full. If you can't see, you need to have precise flow control and timing, and despite all that will still regularly overflow or underfill the cup.