by boar_d_laze on Wed Jan 18, 2012 9:27 pm
I'm very happy with my La Cimbali Max/Hybrid.
It's a great grinder in terms of grind quality, but there are some things which may or may not be issues depending on how you use your grinder.
The La Cimbali doser does not come off. So, if you want "doserless," read no further.
Without grinding away some plastic inside the doser you cannot get to the shoot to clean it with a brush.
The grinder wants coffee in the hopper or it will "popcorn." It's a poor choice for anyone who wants to single dose. Because the hopper requires removing screws to separate from the grinder, it's also not a good choice for someone who changes coffees frequently.
It doesn't come with a timer, which means you'll want to add something like a darkroom timer. While that's hardly difficult or inconvenient, it isn't free either. Consider the extra expense -- not far from $200 for a high quality, new timer like a Gralab -- before calculating the "such a deal" aspects.
Compared to some of the other titans -- especially the Malkoenigs, it's relatively slow and noisy (although not by "regular" grinder standards.
Espresso ONLY! Fineness is adjusted by a very precise, mechanical worm drive driven by a small knob. I forget how many turns it takes to go from an espresso grind to the sort of medium grind appropriate for a pour over, but you'd have to measure time in geological units.
Enough poor mouthing.
Grind quality is excellent. I recently took a class which supplied a Malkonig E30 and a Mazzer Kony for grinding. Not to wander too far afield, the Malkonig is a lot easier to use, but the Kony puts a little more nuance in the cup. Each one is a great grinder, and their respective grind qualities are easily a match for the Max Hybrid's. But neither's is superior. That puts the Cimbali in some pretty exclusive company.
Like darn near anything labeled "La Cimbali," the Max Hybrid is extraordinarily well built. (The design itself is a mixture of La Cimbali and Chris Nachtrieb of Chris Coffee. Chris had La Cimbali put their extraordinary Max burr set into the very friendly Junior body. FWIW, the "Hybrid" in the name refers to the Max/Junior confluence and not the "hybrid" flat + conical burr set.)
Even with the timer, it's relatively inexpensive considering the grind quality.
Ergonomics are excellent. Best doser I've ever used, and a real clean sweeper at that.
Design is a matter of taste, but if you've got a lot of industrial looking stainless in your kitchen/coffee-room; the Max Hybrid will certainly fit.
Under counter? Yes, indeed.
The La Cimbali's restrictions have no effect on the way I make coffee. Doser, check; Don't change coffee too often, check; Keep beans in the hopper, check; Not too noisy for my house, check; etc. Don't sweep the chute or take the damn thing apart too frequently, check. But, I'm not you.
Given my preferences and practices, and factoring in the slightly lower price, I'd buy the Cimbali again -- especially if looking for something short enough to fit under a 17" kitchen cabinet. The Malkonig ProM would be my second choice. I'm pretty sure the Versa Lab would drive me nuts. After those three, the quality drop off is pretty steep unless you're amenable to removing the hopper every time you want to store your grinder under those famous cabinets.
BDL